От Chestnut
К Игорь Куртуков
Дата 18.03.2005 19:42:39
Рубрики Современность; 1917-1939;

Почему не знает? Он что -- засекречен? (-)
От Игорь Куртуков
К Chestnut (18.03.2005 19:42:39)
Дата 18.03.2005 19:45:47

Похоже на то

Никто из участвующих в обсуждении ничего конкретного сказать не смог.
От Chestnut
К Игорь Куртуков (18.03.2005 19:45:47)
Дата 18.03.2005 23:37:47

Re: Похоже на...

>Никто из участвующих в обсуждении ничего конкретного сказать не смог.

Franco was born at the coastal city and naval centre of El Ferrol in Galicia (northwestern Spain). His family life was not entirely happy, for Franco's father, an officer in the Spanish Naval Administrative Corps, was eccentric, wasteful, and somewhat dissolute. More disciplined and serious than other boys his age, Franco was close to his mother, a pious and conservative upper middle-class Roman Catholic. Like four generations and his elder brother before him, Franco was originally destined for a career as a naval officer, but reduction of admissions to the Naval Academy forced him to choose the army. In 1907, only 14 years old, he entered the Infantry Academy at Toledo, graduating three years later.

Franco volunteered for active duty in the colonial campaigns in Spanish Morocco that had begun in 1909 and was transferred there in 1912 at age 19. The following year he was promoted to first lieutenant in an elite regiment of native Moroccan cavalry. At a time in which many Spanish officers were characterized by sloppiness and lack of professionalism, young Franco quickly showed his ability to command troops effectively and soon won a reputation for complete professional dedication. He devoted great care to the preparation of his unit's actions and paid more attention than was common to the troops' well-being. Reputed to be scrupulously honest, introverted, and a man of comparatively few intimate friends, he was known to shun all frivolous amusements. In 1915 he became the youngest captain in the Spanish army. The following year he was seriously wounded by a bullet in the abdomen and returned to Spain to recover. In 1920 he was chosen to be second in command of the newly organized Spanish Foreign Legion, succeeding to full command in 1923. That year he also married Carmen Polo, with whom he had a daughter. During crucial campaigns against the Moroccan rebels, the legion played a decisive role in bringing the revolt to an end. Franco became a national hero, and in 1926, at age 33, he was promoted to brigadier general. At the beginning of 1928, he was named director of the newly organized General Military Academy in Saragossa.

After the fall of the monarchy in 1931, the leaders of the new Spanish Republic undertook a major and much-needed military reform, and Franco's career was temporarily halted. The General Military Academy was dissolved, and Franco was placed on the inactive list. Though he was an avowed monarchist and held the honour of being a gentleman of the king's chamber, Franco accepted both the new regime and his temporary demotion with perfect discipline. When conservative forces gained control of the republic in 1933, Franco was restored to active command; in 1934 he was promoted to major general. In October 1934, during a bloody uprising of Asturian miners who opposed the admission of three conservative members to the government, Franco was called in to quell the revolt. His success in this operation brought him new prominence. In May 1935 he was appointed chief of the Spanish army's general staff, and he began tightening discipline and strengthening military institutions, although he left many of the earlier reforms in place.

Following a number of scandals that weakened the Radicals, one of the parties of the governing coalition, parliament was dissolved, and new elections were announced for February 1936. By this time the Spanish political parties had split into two factions: the rightist National Bloc and the leftist Popular Front. The left proved victorious in the elections, but the new government was unable to prevent the accelerating dissolution of Spain's social and economic structure. Although Franco had never been a member of a political party, the growing anarchy impelled him to appeal to the government to declare a state of emergency. His appeal was refused, and he was removed from the general staff and sent to an obscure command in the Canary Islands. For some time he refused to commit himself to a military conspiracy against the government, but, as the political system disintegrated, he finally decided to join the rebels.


Franco's military rebellion
At dawn on July 18, 1936, Franco's manifesto acclaiming the military rebellion was broadcast from the Canary Islands, and the same morning the rising began on the mainland. The following day he flew to Morocco and within 24 hours was firmly in control of the protectorate and the Spanish army garrisoning it. After landing in Spain, Franco and his army marched toward Madrid, which was held by the government. When the Nationalist advance came to a halt on the outskirts of the city, the military leaders, in preparation of what they believed was the final assault that would deliver Madrid and the country into their hands, decided to choose a commander in chief, or generalissimo, who would also head the rebel Nationalist government in opposition to the republic. Because of his military ability and prestige, a political record unmarred by sectarian politics and conspiracies, and his proven ability to gain military assistance from Adolf Hitler's Germany and Benito Mussolini's Italy, Franco was the obvious choice. In part because he was not a typical Spanish “political general,” Franco became head of state of the new Nationalist regime on October 1, 1936. The rebel government did not, however, gain complete control of the country for more than three years.

Franco presided over a government that was basically a military dictatorship, but he realized that it needed a regular civil structure to broaden its support; this was to be derived mainly from the antileftist middle classes. On April 19, 1937, he fused the Falange (the Spanish fascist party) with the Carlists and created the rebel regime's official political movement. While expanding the Falange into a more pluralistic group, Franco made it clear that it was the government that used the party and not the other way around. Thus, his regime became an institutionalized authoritarian system, differing in this respect from the fascist party-states of the German and Italian models.

As commander in chief during the Civil War, Franco was a careful and systematic leader. He made no rash moves and suffered only a few temporary defeats as his forces advanced slowly but steadily; the only major criticism directed at him during the campaign was that his strategy was frequently unimaginative. Nevertheless, because of the relatively superior military quality of his army and the continuation of heavy German and Italian assistance, Franco won a complete and unconditional victory on April 1, 1939.



In hoc signo vinces
От Игорь Куртуков
К Chestnut (18.03.2005 23:37:47)
Дата 19.03.2005 16:04:03

В приведеном тексте нет...

... никаких фактов позволяющих сделать вывод, что Франко был "хороший полководец". Видно, что он имел хороший карьерный рост. А как он командовал войсками в бою или сражении - не видно.
От Chestnut
К Игорь Куртуков (19.03.2005 16:04:03)
Дата 20.03.2005 02:09:57

Re: В приведеном

>... никаких фактов позволяющих сделать вывод, что Франко был "хороший полководец". Видно, что он имел хороший карьерный рост. А как он командовал войсками в бою или сражении - не видно.


In 1920 he was chosen to be second in command of the newly organized Spanish Foreign Legion, succeeding to full command in 1923. .... During crucial campaigns against the Moroccan rebels, the legion played a decisive role in bringing the revolt to an end. Franco became a national hero, and in 1926, at age 33, he was promoted to brigadier general.

In hoc signo vinces
От Игорь Куртуков
К Chestnut (20.03.2005 02:09:57)
Дата 20.03.2005 05:54:04

Re: В приведеном

>In 1920 he was chosen to be second in command of the newly organized Spanish Foreign Legion, succeeding to full command in 1923.

Это то что я назвал успешной карьерой.

> During crucial campaigns against the Moroccan rebels, the legion played a decisive role in bringing the revolt to an end.

Это успешная кампания. Успех не тождественен "хорошести". Можно быть плохим полководцем, но выиграть кампанию например потому, что противник еще хуже. Или потому, что не зависящие от командных решений обстоятельства благоприятствовали одной из армий.

Вобщем не дает достаточных оснований для характеристики как хорошего полководца.

>Franco became a national hero, and in 1926, at age 33, he was promoted to brigadier general.

Национальный герой совсем не обязательно хороший полководец.
От Chestnut
К Chestnut (20.03.2005 02:09:57)
Дата 20.03.2005 02:11:08

а также

As commander in chief during the Civil War, Franco was a careful and systematic leader. He made no rash moves and suffered only a few temporary defeats as his forces advanced slowly but steadily; the only major criticism directed at him during the campaign was that his strategy was frequently unimaginative.

In hoc signo vinces
От Андю
К Chestnut (20.03.2005 02:11:08)
Дата 20.03.2005 03:04:31

Можно и иначе выделить. :-) (+)

Приветствую !

>As commander in chief during the Civil War, Franco was a careful and systematic leader. He made no rash moves and suffered only a few temporary defeats as his forces advanced slowly but steadily; the only major criticism directed at him during the campaign was that his strategy was frequently unimaginative.

А вообще то, да, голословно всё это. Разве что "Спартак, чемпион !!!" покричать. :-)

Андрей.

Соблюдать правила гигиены ещё важнее, чем правила безопасности.
От Chestnut
К Андю (20.03.2005 03:04:31)
Дата 20.03.2005 15:23:48

Re: Можно и...

>А вообще то, да, голословно всё это. Разве что "Спартак, чемпион !!!" покричать. :-)


Гы, киевлянину кричать "Спартак -- чемпион"? :-)))))))

Что-то у Вас часто сие выражение попадаться стало в постах. Ностальгия мучит никак?

In hoc signo vinces
От Андю
К Chestnut (20.03.2005 15:23:48)
Дата 20.03.2005 21:24:21

Верно. А ностальгия есть по временам киевского Динамо эдак 1985-88 гг. (+)

Приветствую !

>Гы, киевлянину кричать "Спартак -- чемпион"? :-)))))))

Ну, я вот из Подмосковья (по прописке), а всегда за Динамо (К.) болел и ничего. ;-)

Офф-топик закругляю.

Андрей.

Соблюдать правила гигиены ещё важнее, чем правила безопасности.